The Follow-Up Sequence That Converts Prospects Into $10-100K+ Clients

How to turn “not now” into “let’s do it” (and never let a deal slip through the cracks)

November 2, 2025
Read Time: 7 minutes

Most people think sales is about the first conversation. The reality? The money is in the follow-up. But not all follow-up is the same. There’s a world of difference between following up after your initial outreach and following up after you’ve delivered an audit.

Let’s break down both, step by step.

Part 1: Follow-Up After Initial Outreach

Philosophy:
Persistence wins. Most deals are lost because people give up too soon. Your job is to stay top of mind, be consistent, and always add value, without being annoying.

The Biggest Mistake:
Most consultants send one or two messages, get no response, and move on. Or they have a great first call, but never follow up with next steps. The result? The prospect forgets about you, and the opportunity dies.

The Step-by-Step Process:

1. First Message:
   Send your initial outreach (warm or cold). Make it personal, relevant, and focused on their business.

2. First Follow-Up (3 days later):
   If no response, send a short, polite nudge.
   "Hey [Name], just bumping this up in case it got buried. Let me know if this is on your radar."

3. Second Follow-Up (3 days later):
   Still no response? Add a bit of value or a new angle.
   "Hi [Name], I just published a case study on how we helped [similar company] save $50K with AI automation. Thought you might find it interesting."

4. Third Follow-Up (3 days later):
   If still nothing, give them an easy out and a future touchpoint.
   "If now’s not the right time, would you like me to check in again in a month or two?"

5. Pause and Re-Engage:
   If you still get no response, pause for a month, then check in again with something new (a win, a new case study, or a relevant industry update).

How to Know They’re Warming Up:

• They start asking questions (about process, pricing, or results)

• They respond quickly and thoughtfully

• They engage with your content or case studies

Mindset:
You’re not being pushy. You’re being professional. Most people are busy, distracted, or just not ready, until they are. Your job is to be there when the timing is right.

Part 2: Follow-Up After Audit Delivery

Philosophy:
After you deliver the audit, the prospect needs time to digest, discuss with their team, and process your recommendations. But if you disappear, you lose momentum. The key is to follow up with value, not pressure.

The Biggest Mistake:
Consultants deliver the audit, send the final deck, and then wait. They assume if the client wants to move forward, they’ll reach out. In reality, clients often need a nudge, a reminder, or a new reason to act.

The Step-by-Step Process:

1. Deliver the Audit:
   Present your findings, answer questions, and outline the implementation roadmap.

2. Wait Two Weeks:
   Give them space to digest, talk to their team, and come up with questions.

3. First Follow-Up (2 weeks after delivery):
   Check in with a value-add.
   "Hi [Name], just checking in to see if you had any questions about the audit or the implementation plan. I’ve also seen a few new AI use cases in your industry that might be relevant, happy to share if you’re interested."

4. Second Follow-Up (1 week later):
   If no response, share a new case study, testimonial, or a quick win you’ve seen elsewhere.
   "Hi [Name], wanted to share a recent success story from another client who implemented [solution]. They saw [result] in just a few weeks. Let me know if you’d like to discuss how this could work for you."

5. Ongoing Nurture:
   If they’re still not ready, ask if you can check in again in a month or two. Keep them on your content list and share relevant wins or insights as they come up.

How to Know They’re Ready:

• They ask for a follow-up call or more information

• They start asking about next steps, pricing, or timelines

• They engage with your content or reply to your check-ins

Mindset:
You’re not chasing. You’re staying present. You’re making it easy for them to say yes when the timing is right.

Using Content as Follow-Up

Every new case study, client win, or industry insight is a reason to reach out.

• “Just published a new case study on how we saved $50K for a manufacturing firm, thought you might find it interesting.”

• “Saw this new AI use case in your industry and thought of you.”

• “We just helped another client automate their onboarding process, let me know if you want to see how it works.”

Content isn’t just for marketing. It’s your best follow-up tool.

Real Examples of Follow-Up That Closed Big Deals

Didac’s six-figure deal didn’t happen on the first call. He followed up, shared new wins, and kept the conversation alive until the timing was right.

Alexandra’s $35K implementation came after a free audit and multiple check-ins. She kept adding value, sharing new insights, and making it easy for the client to move forward. (see last weeks newsletter for more details on these 2 deals)

The pattern is clear: Consistent, value-driven follow-up closes deals.

The Mindset Shift

The biggest difference between consultants who close big deals and those who don’t? Consistency and conviction.

You don’t need to be pushy. You need to be present. You need to follow up when you say you will. You need to keep adding value, even when you don’t get an immediate yes.

Confidence comes from action. The more you follow up, the more wins you’ll get. The more wins you get, the more confident you’ll become.

The best Vibe Consultants aren’t built. They’re made, one follow-up at a time.

See you next week,

– Andrew

P.S. Ready to build your own Vibe Consulting business? Book a 1:1 strategy call here to see if you’re a good fit for my personal coaching program.

💡 How I Can Help

AI Audit Workshop ($9): Get the complete step-by-step system for conducting professional AI audits. Includes all templates, interview scripts, opportunity matrix frameworks, ROI calculators, and presentation slides I use to charge $10K+ per audit.

Start Your AI Consulting Business: Join other entrepreneurs building their AI audit businesses. Get the 90-day roadmap, real-time feedback from me, all automation workflows, outbound campaign setups, and everything you need to start landing clients.